Polish power relations with russia have already been burdensome for many years, with warsaw keen to diversify from its east neighbour.

Polands energy choice manufacturers can be close to attaining their particular objective, but they are additionally learning the difficult way that no-cost areas are a double-edged sword.

On may 26, westward moves of propane through the europol pipeline, one of many transit routes for russian gasoline to european countries via poland, stumbled on a whole halt for just about every day only to resume at way more volatile levels.

This followed the termination of a long-term transportation agreement between russia and poland nine days earlier in the day. since that time, gazprom happens to be liberated to reserve ability at regular auctions under eu guidelines in place of becoming tied up down by a less versatile contract arrangement with poland.

Gazprom, as just big user of europol, has gained an edge as it can deal the cost of transportation down. the 3rd one-fourth of 2020 it is spending money on a polish transportation tariff which 2.5 times not as much as for ukrainian transportation.

Earlier this month, the polish regulator authorized a 16.5 percent tariff increase for gas transit via europol efficient next year, designating the anticipated additional profits for the construction of this baltic pipe.

But hopes for additional transit revenue might be simply a pipe-dream because amid a gas supply glut in european countries, gazprom has now started treating europol as a balancing course, completing it only after all its other pipelines with ship-or-pay plans (like nord stream and ukraine) were utilised.

Polands apparent loss in negotiating energy also includes future gasoline purchases too, because polands gasoline supply contract with gazprom is set to expire after 2022.

Pgnig, the polish condition gas and oil company, has formally informed gazprom your contract will never be restored as the country is likely to switch to approach deliveries of lng and norwegian pipeline fuel.

Polish authorities programs of replacing gazprom gas with us liquefied natural gas, dubbed particles of freedom, appeared to bode well for transatlantic cooperation for which poland is attempting to become a principal conduit of us policies in europe.

They even appeared to provide poland reduced lng costs in contrast to gazproms oil-indexed legacy agreement. what these programs would not consider ended up being the chance of traded gas costs in europe falling below gas prices in the us, a move that has taken the markets by surprise this year.

Poland faces difficult trade-offs between the several targets of fulfilling environmentally friendly targets set-out because of the eu, providing the economy with sufficient volumes of gas, diversifying its fuel offer at competitive costs and guaranteeing power safety.

The polish authorities managed to decrease the share of russian gasoline overall gas imports from 89 % in 2016 to 60 percent in 2019, and the country has now developed a portfolio of both lng, with products from qatar plus the us, and alternative pipeline choices which may replace all its russian gas imports because of the center associated with the 2020s.

Ironically, polands attempts to diversify gas supply resources had already enhanced its negotiating influence with gazprom, but rather of utilizing this benefit to get much better commercial terms, the polish federal government made a decision to literally eliminate russian gas by building pricey option infrastructure.

This included a large lng import facility plus an economically debateable pipeline under the baltic water that mirrors current convenience of bringing norwegian gasoline to northwest europe via germany.

This apparent fixation on ideological physicality in poland has converted into an extortionate politicisation of gas inside polish power economic climate and an unnecessary burning of bridges with russia before brand-new options have now been firmly founded.

Consequently, poland appears to have sacrificed commercial truth on altar of political need, whilst has effortlessly cut-off among its less expensive and cleaner types of offer whilst lowering its negotiating position.

At the same time, the results of a recent arbitration situation between pgnig and gazprom reveal that reducing the price of russian imports might have been attained without building almost so much diversification infrastructure.

Embracing the possibilities agreed to last gasoline consumers by the liberalised, competitive wholesale trading fuel markets in northwest european countries may have achieved exactly the same targets without burdening poland with high priced and dangerous brand new projects.

Vitaly yermakov is a senior research fellow within oxford institute for energy studies and a former commodity strategist for sberbank cib

The commodities note is an on-line discourse on business from financial instances